Wednesday, May 21, 2014

UCLA Judicial Board: Israel Trips are not a "Conflict of Interest"

Plans by extremist JVP,  SJP and other anti-Israel groups to intimidate and silence students at UCLA have failed.  The UCLA Judicial Board has ruled that students educational trips to Israel do not present a "conflict of interest"  for those in student government. Members of the student government who had been on trips to Israel sponsored by pro-Israel organizations did not need to abstain from voting on divestment.   The Judicial Board’s full opinion will be released by June 4.

Via The Jewish Journal

UCLA’s undergraduate judicial board — the student government’s equivalent of the Supreme Court — ruled Wednesday in a 4-0 vote that student government officers may take sponsored trips to Israel without it constituting a conflict of interest. Two of the judges abstained.

The ruling marks only the latest conflict between the UCLA chapter of Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP) and pro-Israel students on the campus. SJP filed a complaint in April against students Sunny Singh and Lauren Rogers, charging that they created a potential conflict of interest when they went on free trips to Israel, with the Anti-Defamation League and the American Jewish Committee, respectively.

The pro-Palestinian group asked the court to review the legitimacy of the votes cast by Singh and Rogers last February towards a SJP-sponsored resolution that called on UCLA’s administration to divest from companies that do business in the West Bank. That resolution failed 7-5. Although the ballot was secret, the going assumption is that both Singh and Rogers voted against the resolution.

On the evening of May 15, the Judicial Board heard about 4.5 hours of arguments, with both Singh and Rogers undergoing cross-examination by SJP’s student counsel, Dana Saifan, who questioned Singh about the contents of a liability clause ADL asked him to sign before his trip, asking why he didn’t submit into evidence his entire ADL trip application. 

Singh said that his application was filled out on an old laptop that he no longer had in his possession.

Singh’s and Rogers’ counsel called as witnesses ADL regional director Amanda Susskind and Robert Peckar, immediate past national board chair of Project Interchange, the name of the AJC-sponsored Israel trip. They both argued that their motivation to bring Singh and Rogers to Israel was not a quid pro quo. They had no expectation and made no request for either to vote against anti-Israel resolutions in the student government.

Read it all here

No comments: