For those of you who bemoan the lack of leadership from Hillel on behalf of pro-Israel students, I present to you an email from Rabbi Serena Eisenberg, the Executive Director of Hillel at Stanford.
Dear
Friend of Hillel at Stanford,
As
many of you have heard, tomorrow, Tuesday, February 10th, the Associated
Students of Stanford University (ASSU) Senate will consider a bill recommending
university divestment from companies doing business in Israel. I write
to provide some additional context and information in advance of the
vote.
A two-thirds majority is needed for the non-binding bill
to pass. Our students' work reaching out to the senators indicates that equal
handfuls of student senators have made their decisions to vote one way or the
other; the rest are undecided or may abstain. Jewish students have been
advocating and lobbying in a variety of ways, including meeting with individual
senators, utilizing social media, holding campus events, and developing
collateral educational and PR materials. Student leaders developed a website
(Coalition for Peace) and Facebook page, and launched a petition drive in conjunction with supportive alumni which to
date has gathered over 3,000 signatures in just two weeks. A comprehensive
binder was compiled and provided to each student senator, including
counterpoints to the bill, collected letters (from Stanford Nobel Laureates and
professors), and additional materials.
In addition to the student senate vote on Tuesday, there
may be an effort to place a divestment referendum on the spring, campus-wide
student election ballot. And students advocating for divestment have asked the
university's Advisory Panel on Investment Responsibility, which vets investment
issues and makes recommendations to the Board of Trustees, to review their
request for divestment and recommend it to the university trustees.
The "Stanford Out of Occupied Palestine" Coalition
(SOOP) which proposed the bill has been extremely sophisticated and active in
the past year. The coalition includes at least 18 campus organizations, and
their efforts have included extensively posting flyers in all dorms and on a
wide variety of Stanford list-serves; door- to- door solicitation of signatures
for a pro-divestment petition; numerous op-eds; a sophisticated website and
frequent events.
This year's campaign follows many years of significant
divestment efforts, including student senate bills brought and defeated in 2007,
2010, and Spring, 2013. In Fall, 2013, the national conference for the Students
for Justice in Palestine brought 300 pro-BDS Palestinian student activists to
Stanford. Over time, the divestment movement has developed increasingly
sophisticated messages and growing support even among Jewish students and
community members. We no longer see periodic attempts, but rather a constant
stream of programming engaging students as well as faculty. This year in particular, the climate has felt palpably
intimidating and hostile for some Jewish students. There is a trend for students
affiliated with Students for Justice in
Palestine (SJP) to demur dialogue with students who identify as Zionist or
pro-Israel (either Jews or gentiles), claiming to do so would "normalize the
occupation." This stance erodes civil discourse and is at odds with the values
of any university.
Hillel at Stanford is working with senior university
administrators to address these concerns and advocate for an educational
environment for all students to feel safe to clarify and express their diverse
identities and opinions. In past weeks, Hillel at Stanford has presented many
opportunities for civil discourse for both the Jewish and wider university
communities with our Ask Big Questions initiative, as well as convening forums,
town hall meetings, and panel discussions
on Israel/Palestine issues. Next week we will host a Shabbat dinner for
students to process after the vote with a range of Stanford
professors.
Student mobilization these past weeks arose from a
robust foundation of year-round Hillel at Stanford Israel strategies to empower
our 1800 Jewish graduate and undergraduate students. Our Hillel staff includes
a full-time Israel Fellow and a strong program team who benefits from regular
and intensive professional development including staff trainings, leading
Stanford Birthright trips, the Hillel International professional's trip, and the
Hartman Hillel fellowship.
We are TREMENDOUSLY grateful for the support and
partnership of so many people and organizations who are helping students to
reframe and defeat this acute campus issue, which many believe is but one tactic
in a much larger strategy of isolating Israel through Boycott, Divestment and
Sanctions (BDS). In just the past two weeks, our students have benefited from
guidance and resources from the JCRC, Hillel International, the Israel on Campus
Coalition, the Israeli Consulate, Ameinu, the American Jewish Committee, Stand
with Us, BlueStar Media, and our long-term partnerships with Taglit-Birthright,
AIPAC, Jstreet, and the David Project (plus others we are surely forgetting to
mention!) Each of these partners contributes to a strong and pluralistic
pro-Israel campus climate. While we continue to believe that our local Hillel
team of student leaders, staff, faculty, board, and alumni is best positioned to
coordinate and organize among the various organizations, we are grateful for the
valuable input and diverse points of view that have significantly strengthened
our impact. For example, one of the (non-Jewish) student senators went on a
David Project Israel trip this winter break, and he could ultimately be one of
the swing votes in Stanford's student senate vote this Tuesday.
We will update you following the ASSU Senate
vote Tuesday night, and Hillel at Stanford will continue to work
tirelessly to sustain and strengthen the impact of robust Israel educational,
advocacy, and travel opportunities throughout the year, for Stanford students who are and will invariably become
leaders at all levels of local, national and international life.
Sincerely,
Rabbi
Serena Eisenberg
Executive
Director, Hillel at Stanford